Evolution of the Immune System



Evolution of the Immune System



All animals, regardless of their complexity or evolutionary history, must be able to defend themselves against invading microorganisms that might cause disease or death. Both invertebrates and vertebrates possess innate immune defenses triggered by “danger signals” such as tissue damage or microbial invasion. The mammalian type of adaptive immune system, however, evolved only after the emergence of the jawless fishes or cyclostomes. Thus, adaptive immune mechanisms such as antibody production or antigen-responsive lymphocytes are found only in the advanced vertebrates.


The diverse subsystems of the innate immune system evolved at different stages of phylogeny in response to the threats imposed by various pathogens. Different subsystems may have changed in relative importance based on specific needs or changes in anatomy and physiology. The relative contribution of these subsystems in any individual species probably reflects the optimal mixture that evolved to ensure maximal protection for that species. Specific components of the innate immune system may therefore vary greatly among species, or even within the same class of organism.


Changes in innate subsystem use clearly occurred at different stages of phylogeny. Natural killer (NK) cells, the use of type I interferons (IFNs), and certain specialized leukocytes such as eosinophils and basophils occur only in vertebrates. Likewise subsystems that depend on an intact vasculature do not work in invertebrates that have an open circulatory system.



Immunity in Invertebrates


Invertebrates are classified based on the presence of a body cavity or coelom (Figure 40-1). The acoelomates include the sponges and coelenterates (jellyfish and sea anemones). The coelomates evolved further into two major lines. One line includes the annelids, mollusks, and arthropods, collectively called the protostomes. The other line, including the echinoderms, protochordates, and chordates, is called the deuterostomes. It is from deuterostome-like ancestors that the vertebrates evolved. Invertebrates rely exclusively on physical barriers and innate immune defenses to exclude microbial invaders.




Physical Barriers


Physical barriers are most obvious in the arthropods. Tough chitinous exoskeletons can protect arthropods against all types of attackers. The horseshoe crab (Limulus polyphemus) not only has a hard exoskeleton but also can protect itself against bacteria in polluted water by secreting a specialized glycoprotein through pores in the carapace. On contact with endotoxins, this glycoprotein coagulates, sealing the pores and immobilizing any invading bacteria. Likewise, if bacteria enter horseshoe crab hemolymph, clotting factors are activated by lipopolysaccharides (LPSs) and result in local clot formation that traps invaders. Other invertebrates such as the coelenterates, annelids, mollusks, and echinoderms secrete masses of sticky mucus when attacked, thus immobilizing potential invaders. This mucus may contain antimicrobial peptides.



Innate Immunity


Invertebrates use three major innate defense subsystems: phagocytosis by blood or body cavity cells; protease cascades that lead to fluid clotting, melanin formation, and opsonization; and the production of a wide variety of antimicrobial peptides. Their initial defensive response is to use rapidly attacking phagocytic cells. This can be highly efficient, killing more than 99% of the invading bacteria. The few surviving bacteria, however, are somewhat more resistant to phagocytic cells than normal. These survivors induce the second stage of the response, the production of potent antibacterial peptides that wipe out any surviving bacteria and ensure that none survive to permit the development of resistance.



Phagocytosis


In 1884, the Russian biologist Elie Mechnikov discovered phagocytosis when examining starfish larvae. He showed that mobile cells attacked rose thorns introduced into the coelom of these larvae. Since then, phagocytosis has been shown to be a universal defense mechanism within the animal kingdom. Several different types of phagocytic cells are recognized in coelomate invertebrates. They occur in blood (hemocytes) and in the body cavity (coelomocytes). These cells behave like mammalian phagocytes and undertake chemotaxis, adherence, ingestion, and digestion. They contain proteases, and in some invertebrates, such as mollusks, they produce potent oxidants. Some phagocytes can aggregate and plug wounds to prevent bleeding. Where phagocytic cells cannot control the invaders, they may be walled off in cellular nodules somewhat similar to vertebrate granulomas.


Invertebrates can produce cytokine-like molecules. One of these, an interleukin-1 (IL-1)-like molecule, may activate phagocytic cells and stimulate phagocytosis. LPS stimulation of mollusk hemocytes may stimulate the release of TNF-like, IL-6-like, or IL-1-like proteins. Cell surface adhesive proteins such as integrins are found in arthropods such as Drosophila or freshwater crayfish. These may promote hemocyte degranulation and activation of the prophenoloxidase system.



Prophenoloxidase (proPO)-Activating System


This system, found in arthropod hemolymph, consists of multiple enzymes that, when activated, generate a cascade of proteases leading to the production of the inert polymeric pigment melanin (Figure 40-2). The system is activated by the interaction of bacterial and fungal LPSs, peptidoglycans, and glucans with hemocytes. Activation also occurs through cuticular and hemolymph proteases. The proPO system generates phenoloxidase, a sticky enzyme that binds to foreign surfaces. This enzyme acts on tyrosine and dopamine to generate melanin and deposit it around inflammatory sites. Melanin polymer is deposited in the tissues surrounding invaders to form an impermeable barrier that blocks their nutrient uptake. Oxidizing agents and other antimicrobial molecules are also generated during melanin synthesis.




Antimicrobial Peptides


When bacteria infect insects, their pathogen-associated molecular patterns (PAMPs) are recognized by toll-like receptors (TLRs) and other receptors. Because of their dependence on innate immunity, invertebrates have evolved many different pattern-recognition receptors. In the sea urchin (Strongylocentrotus purpuratus), for example, there are 222 different TLR genes and more than 200 NOD-like genes. TLRs have been identified in even the least developed invertebrates such as the sponges. In contrast to mammals, in which TLRs directly recognize pathogens, drosophila Toll is activated by a protein ligand (called spätzle) that is generated after pathogen recognition.


As a result of activation of these pathways, arthropod cells produce diverse antimicrobial peptides. These peptides are mainly produced in the fat body (the functional equivalent of the mammalian liver), although some may be produced locally on body surfaces. The peptides appear about 2 hours after bacterial invasion and reach peak levels at 24 hours. In some insects, the activity is short lived and disappears in a few days; in others, it may last for several months. About 400 different antimicrobial peptides, including defensins, have been identified in invertebrates. Invertebrates also generate lectins that can bind microbial carbohydrates such as LPSs, glucans, mannans, and sialic acid. These include C-type lectins and pentraxins and are thus analogous to mammalian acute-phase proteins. These invertebrate lectins act as opsonins and enhance activation of the prophenoloxidase system. Insects also produce the antibacterial enzyme lysozyme.


The complement system is ancient, with some components originating long before the emergence of vertebrates. Two complement-like proteins, C3 and Bf, have been traced back as far as the coelenterates. It is likely that the ancestral C3 was proteolytically activated by Bf and then formed a covalent thioester bond with foreign molecules. When the chordates emerged around 900 Mya, molecules such as MBL and the MASPS were recruited to the complement system to establish the lectin pathway. Proteins homologous to mammalian MBL, ficolins, MASPs, C3, C2/factor B, and a C3 receptor have been identified in ascidians (sea squirts). Thus invertebrates have both alternative and lectin pathways. Once activated through these pathways, invertebrate complement can opsonize microbial invaders.



RNA Interference


The intracellular RNA interference pathway (RNAi) is a gene-silencing system that appears to have evolved to prevent viruses from replicating within infected cells. It is especially important as a defense system in invertebrates (Figure 40-3). RNA normally occurs only in a single-stranded (ss) form. Long segments of double-stranded RNA (dsRNA) are not present in healthy eukaryotic cells, but they do occur if a cell is infected by RNA viruses. When a virus-infected cell produces dsRNA, it is rapidly degraded into many short fragments by an enzyme called dicer. These fragments, or small-interfering RNAs (siRNAs) are then stabilized by a protein complex called the RNA-induced silencing complex (RISC). Half of these siRNAs will be complementary to the viral messenger RNAs (mRNAs) and as a result can serve as templates and bind them. Once these viral mRNAs have been captured by binding to the RISC complex, they are degraded rapidly, and viral replication effectively blocked.




Adaptive Immunity


Invertebrates do not make antibodies. The ability to mount adaptive immune responses arose with the jawed vertebrates. Nevertheless, proteins belonging to the immunoglobulin superfamily have been detected in arthropods, echinoderms, and mollusks as well as in protochordates. Some of these proteins can bind specifically to foreign molecules. In insects, there is a protein member of the immunoglobulin superfamily called Dscam that can be extensively diversified by alternate splicing. Isoforms of Dscam are expressed in immune tissues and secreted as soluble proteins into the hemolymph. Drosophila species have the potential to express more than 18,000 isoforms of this molecule. Individual hemocytes may express 14 to 50 forms of Dscam that can bind to bacteria and enhance their phagocytosis. It is not known how self-recognition by Dscam is prevented.



Graft Rejection


Invertebrates can reject allografts and xenografts. For example, cell-mediated allograft rejection occurs in sponges, coelenterates, annelids, and echinoderms. When two identical sponge colonies are placed side by side and made to grow in contact with each other, no reaction occurs. If, however, sponges from two different colonies are made to grow in contact, local destruction of tissue occurs along the area of contact as each sponge attempts to destroy the other.


Annelids such as earthworms can reject both allografts and xenografts. The rejection of xenografts (from other species of earthworms) takes about 20 days. Cells invade the graft, and the grafted tissue turns white, swells, becomes edematous, and eventually dies. If the recipient worms are grafted with a second piece of skin from the same donor, the second graft is rejected faster than the first. This ability to reject second grafts rapidly may be adoptively transferred by coelomocytes from sensitized animals.



Immunity in Vertebrates


There are seven classes of living vertebrates: jawless fish, cartilaginous fish, bony fish, amphibians, reptiles, birds, and mammals (Figure 40-4).



The fish emerged about 450 Mya, long before the appearance of the mammals. The least developed living fish belong to the class Agnatha, the jawless fish, or cyclostomes such as the lampreys and the hagfish. Considerably more complex than the cyclostomes are the Chondrichthyes. These are the fish with cartilaginous skeletons and include the rays and sharks (the elasmobranchs). The most complex fish are the bony fish of the class Osteichthyes, which include the overwhelming majority of modern fish, the teleosts. Because they emerged so long ago, fish are much more diverse than mammals, and major differences exist between the immune systems of each class.


There are two major orders of amphibians: the less evolved Urodela, which includes long-bodied, tailed amphibians such as the salamanders and newts; and the Anura, an advanced, tailless order that includes the frogs and toads. These too differ significantly in their immune capabilities.


Three subclasses of reptiles currently exist: the Anapsida, which includes the turtles; the Lepidosaura, which consists of the lizards and snakes; and the Archosauria, which includes the crocodiles and alligators.


The dinosaurs were sufficiently different from true reptiles to be put in a class of their own, the Dinosaura. Although most dinosaurs disappeared 65 Mya at the end of the cretaceous period, their modern descendants are the birds, the members of the class Aves. Unlike the reptiles, birds are (and dinosaurs were) endothermic, or warm blooded. As a result of this, birds share with mammals all the benefits that come from greatly increased physiological and biochemical efficiency.


The mammals consist of three orders: the prototherians, composed of the monotremes, or egg-laying mammals such as the platypus and the echidna; the metatherians, composed of the marsupials or pouched mammals, such as the opossum and the kangaroos; and the eutherians, or placental mammals. The marsupials and eutherians are each other’s closest relatives. The two groups diverged about 172 Mya. The bulk of this book is devoted to the immunology of eutherian mammals.



Immunity in Cyclostomes


The most primitive of living vertebrates are the cyclostomes, the fish without jaws, including the lampreys and the hagfish. These fish make several different types of proteins that can bind to bacteria and enhance phagocytosis by leukocytes. Some of these proteins resemble complement. Their amino acid sequences resemble C3, C4, and C5, and they contain a hidden thioester bond. Lampreys have an ortholog of mammalian C1q that acts as a lectin. Cyclostomes possess both the alternate and lectin pathways but lack the lytic components of complement. The lamprey complement system thus promotes phagocytosis rather than lysis. Lamprey C3 has features of the common ancestor of mammalian C3 and C4, and lamprey factor B resembles the common ancestor of factor B and C2.


Cyclostomes have two types of blood leukocytes. One population resembles monocytes. The other population looks like lymphocytes. Lacking the appropriate recombinases, cyclostomes cannot make antibodies or T cell receptors (TCRs). Instead, they mount a different form of adaptive humoral response through the use of a population of variable lymphocyte receptors (VLRs) unrelated to immunoglobulins. There are major two types of VLR: VLRA is only found on cell surfaces, and VLRB is both secreted and cell bound.


Cyclostomes generate enormous diversity in their VLRs by rearranging their DNA through a process related to gene conversion. This involves inserting variable numbers of leucine-rich modules into an incomplete VLR germline gene. These modules are obtained from a large library of such modules located at each end of the VLR gene and are inserted into the middle of the VLR to generate a functional gene. As a result, the binding site of these VLRs is lined by hypervariable positively selected amino acids. It is calculated that they may be able to assemble as many as 1014 unique receptors in this way. It also appears that each lamprey lymphocyte expresses a specific VLR, suggesting that clonal selection operates in this system. Both types of VLR are probably anchored to the lymphocyte membrane, but VLRB may be released after antigenic stimulation. T cell stimulants enhance VLRA production rather than VLRB.


The production of VLRs therefore represents a very different mechanism from that involving immunoglobulin or TLR diversity, which emerged around the same time (about 450 Mya). This serves to emphasize yet again the benefits of a lymphocyte-based adaptive immune system capable of combating both extracellular and intracellular pathogens. Most advanced vertebrates developed T and B cells. The jawless fish developed VLRA and VLRB.


Hagfish kept under good conditions in a warm environment can reject skin allografts. First grafts take about 72 days at 18° C to be rejected; second grafts are rejected in about 28 days. This rejection is presumably due to innate mechanisms.



Immunological “Big Bang”


The adaptive immune system depends on possession of two key antigen receptor systems, the TCR and the B cell receptor (BCR). Both require the rearrangement of V, D, and J gene segments to form functional, antigen-binding receptors. Invertebrates and cyclostomes cannot rearrange these genes, but cartilaginous and bony fish can. Sometime during the 100 million years between the divergence of jawless and jawed vertebrates and the emergence of cartilaginous and bony fish, about 450 Mya, the enzymatic machinery needed for the recombination of V gene segments emerged. The mechanism of this sudden appearance is unknown. It has been suggested, however, that a transposon carrying the precursors of the recombinase-activating genes RAG1 and RAG2 (most likely a bacterial integrase) was successfully inserted into an immunoglobulin superfamily V-like gene within the germline of the early jawed vertebrates (Figure 40-5). As a result, the immunoglobulin gene could be expressed only after splicing mediated by the RAG enzymes. Thus emerged, in a major evolutionary leap, the ability to generate antigen-binding sites and functional immunoglobulins. This, for the first time, permitted animals to respond specifically to previously encountered antigens. The advantages of this new “improved” system were such that it is now a feature of all jawed vertebrates. This did not, of course, result in discarding of the innate immune defenses. Lectins, the complement system, and the NK cell system remain essential components of vertebrate immunity. It is also important to point out that adaptive immunity did not confer invincibility to infectious agents. It simply made life more difficult for them and conferred an incremental selective advantage on animals with such defenses. The selective advantage of adaptive immunity came with an attendant cost—the potential for autoimmune disease.




Immunity in Jawed Fish


Innate Immunity


Fish employ innate subsystems such as TLRs that are similar to those found in mammals. There are six major families of vertebrate TLRs, and within each family, the TLRs recognize a general class of PAMP. The functions and binding specificities of each TLR family have largely remained unchanged as the vertebrates evolved. (The microbes have not changed, so neither have the TLRs). Orthologs of fish TLR 14, 21, 22, and 23 have not been found in mammals. Fish are resistant to the toxic effects of LPS since fish TLR4 does not recognize LPS. Fish are, of course constantly exposed to aquatic viruses and must defend themselves accordingly. Triggering of the type I IFN system through TLRs is important for fish innate immunity.


In fish inflammatory responses, granulocytes arrive first, and their numbers peak after 12 to 24 hours. This is followed by a wave of macrophages and possibly lymphocytes. The granulocytes are attracted by microbial products and soluble tissue mediators. The response tends to be prolonged, and macrophage numbers peak after 2 to 7 days. In fish, granulocytes originate from the anterior kidney, whereas the macrophages develop from blood monocytes. Fish macrophages are found in many sites, especially the mesentery, splenic ellipsoids, kidney, and atrium of the heart.


Teleost neutrophils are similar in morphology and probably function to mammalian neutrophils and are frequently seen in inflammatory lesions. These neutrophils are phagocytic, and their numbers increase in response to infections. They possess most of the enzymes of mammalian neutrophils. It has been suggested that in some species, neutrophils may carry out their bactericidal function extracellularly rather than intracellularly. The release of oxidants from neutrophils at inflammatory sites may cause severe tissue damage. The fat of fish is highly unsaturated as an adaptation to low temperatures. Polyunsaturated fats are prone to oxidation, and free radicals may therefore oxidize tissue lipids. Fish, therefore, require a powerful means of modulating this response. The brown pigment melanin can quench free radicals, and melanin-containing cells are common in the lymphoid tissues of most bony fish as well as in inflammatory lesions. It probably protects tissues against oxidants produced by phagocytic cells.


Both bony and cartilaginous fish can produce lysozyme, lectins, defensins, complement, and acute-phase proteins. Lysozyme is present in fish eggs and may protect the developing embryo. This fish lysozyme is much more broadly reactive than the mammalian enzyme and is active against both Gram-positive and Gram-negative bacteria. Fish acute-phase proteins include C-reactive protein, serum amyloid A, and serum amyloid P. However, their rise is much less pronounced than in mammals. A mannose-binding lectin has been identified in species such as the Atlantic salmon. Natural cytotoxic cells similar to mammalian NK cells have been described in bony fish. They are produced in the anterior kidney. Antimicrobial peptides called piscidins are found in the mast cells and phagocytic cells of bony fish. Electron microscopy suggests that these peptides can enter phagosomes and probably play a role in killing both extracellular and intracellular invaders.


Cartilaginous and bony fish possess all three complement pathways, namely, the classical, alternate, and lectin activator pathways. The gene duplications required for the development of the classical pathway appeared before the appearance of cartilaginous fish. The fish lytic pathway generates a terminal complement complex similar to that formed in mammals, although it works at a lower optimal temperature (~25° C). Unlike other vertebrates, in which C3 is coded for by a single copy gene, in bony fish, C3 is produced in multiple functional isoforms. For example, rainbow trout have four C3 isoforms, carp have eight, and sea bream have five. They differ in their structure and in their ability to bind to different activating surfaces. It has been suggested that this complement polymorphism may permit the most effective destruction of different invading microorganisms. As in mammals, C3 is the complement component at highest concentration in fish serum. Regulatory proteins similar to C4-binding protein and factor H have been identified in sand bass.



Adaptive Immunity


Both cartilaginous and bony fish can mount adaptive immune responses and have a complete set of lymphoid organs except for a bone marrow (Figure 40-6). They have a thymus located just above the pharynx that arises from the first gill arches. In immature fish, small pores lead from the pharynx to the thymus, suggesting that it may be stimulated directly by antigens in the surrounding water. Thymectomy in fish can lead to prolongation of allograft survival and reduced antibody responses. Antibodies or antigen-binding cells may be detected in the thymus during an immune response, suggesting that it contains both T-like and B-like cells. Although the thymus may involute in response to hormones or season, age involution is inconsistent, and the thymus may be found in many older fish.


< div class='tao-gold-member'>

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Jul 18, 2016 | Posted by in PHARMACOLOGY, TOXICOLOGY & THERAPEUTICS | Comments Off on Evolution of the Immune System

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access