Acupuncture in the Camelid
Acupuncture: History, Philosophy, and Science
Obtaining honest answers to these questions has not always been easy. In part, confusion has existed over what defines acupuncture, when it began, and how it works.1 If one exposes myths and substitutes facts for folklore, acupuncture for camelids becomes a legitimate neuromodulatory intervention instead of a mysterious, magicoreligious modality.
What Is Acupuncture?
It would be wrong to assume that either style of acupuncture practiced in North America resembles that of early China during the time some claim veterinary acupuncture began, in the tenth century, BCE.2,3 Early acupuncture embodied a system of bloodletting and involved large, cutting instruments. Other arcane Chinese methods of cauterizing the skin with branding irons or burning it with smoldering herbs (direct moxibustion) have no home outside of China because they risk unnecessary tissue trauma, discomfort, and nerve injury.4
Although similar techniques are practiced in China still today, Western sensibilities and medical advances have created a gentler, less invasive repertoire of stimulation methods. Today, acupuncturists in the West typically treat their patients with fine, filiform needles specially designed to minimize pain and cellular disruption. Electroacupuncture, that is, a method of passing low amplitude electric current between acupuncture needles in the tissue has become a popular means of augmenting treatment effects. It is generally safe if delivered in accordance with electroacupuncture guidelines.
Early Recognition of the Neural Basis of Acupuncture
Although the ancient Chinese described the effects of acupuncture in metaphoric, agrarian terminology, they were often referring to the somatovisceral and somato-somatic reflexes they witnessed. Even in China, however, the realization that acupuncture worked because the needles influenced nerves started to surface in the middle of the twentieth century. Finally, in the 1970s, reports began filtering into Western journals showing that acupuncture works via the nervous system.5–20 In 1972, the Peking Acupuncture Anesthesia Coordinating Group reported that “about half of the known acupuncture points are located right over various nerves, and the rest are within half a centimeter of one or another nerve. From this, the conclusion was drawn that acupuncture acts, in fact, on the nervous system, and it is through a nerve that the stimulus produced by needling or applying a mild electric current is transmitted to a certain part or organ of the body where it effects a cure or brings about a state of analgesia.”21
At about that time, articles linking acupuncture and the autonomic nervous system reached the veterinary medical literature.15 Over the ensuing decade, recognition of the interrelationship between acupuncture and the nervous system strengthened further.16 In 2004, Kothbauer clearly outlined the relationship between acupuncture points and nerves in his review of steps toward anatomic verification of point locations in cattle.8
How Acupuncture Works: From Somatic Afferent Fibers to the Brain
In very simple terms, acupuncture begins as an afferent signal initiated near the needling site that travels centripetally into the central nervous system (CNS). Propagated neural information courses along the neurovascular routes comprising the acupuncture channels. These action potentials converge on spinal cord and brainstem centers within the CNS.11 Some impulses arriving at the cord may (1) send efferent signals back out to the periphery (leading to antidromic activation of free nerve endings at the site of needling), (2) loop into related visceral neural networks and alter internal organ function in a spinal segmental manner, (3) foster endogenous opioid release in the dorsal horn of the spinal cord to reduce spinal facilitation, or “wind-up,” and block pain, or (4) proceed to higher centers in the brain, altering neuroendocrine activities, limbic system functions, and the conscious recognition of pain.
Note that if acupuncture worked by moving energy and not by nerves as so many unfortunately still believe, its effects would continue regardless of neural health or integrity. However, partial neurologic injuries cause the needling effects to diminish or disappear, depending on the locus of the lesion.22 Acupuncture has no effect in the face of complete denervation.
In fact, the neural basis of acupuncture is so clear that some authors have replaced the conventional alphanumeric naming system of acupuncture points and channels with names referencing the relevant nerves, not remote and possibly irrelevant organs.23 As early as 1974, Dr. Patrick Wall, the co-developer of the gate control theory, felt that a new classification system based on acupuncture points and nerves was overdue.24
Structural Facts about Acupuncture Point Anatomy
The process of selecting points for treatment depends on the patient’s problem and avenues that invoke effective neuromodulation. For example, needling points around a painful joint augment regional circulation, venous drainage, muscle relaxation, and analgesia. Adding points along associated spinal nerve routes (i.e., along the Bladder channel) and peripheral nerve pathways associated with sensation, autonomic control, and motor function further dampens pain transmission. Nonspecific, homeostatic points such as Stomach 36 (ST36) squelch pain and counter inflammation predominantly through autonomic neuromodulation and opioidergic effects.25
A general grouping of points with similar structure–function relationships and clinical properties are listed in Box 54-1.
Physiologic Influences of Acupuncture Stimulation
Physiologic consequences (including changes in blood flow) from acupuncture stimulation depend on the types of somatic afferent fibers involved.26 The frequency of stimulation, whether delivered manually or electrically, may also differentially excite various groups of somatic afferents, resulting in different outcomes in autonomic reflex responses.26 Insufficient afferent stimulation fails to deliver the desired effect.27
In addition to treating pain and neuromusculoskeletal impairments, acupuncture may influence visceral function via spinal segmental interneuronal activation. As indicated previously, points located longitudinally in paraspinal regions (along the Bladder channel) stimulate the dorsal primary rami of the spinal nerve roots, which then affect spinal cord segments that are simultaneously overseeing visceral sympathetic drive. Because somatic and visceral inputs converge via common interneurons, stimulation of these loci influence and transmit feedback pertaining to internal organ function.28 This explains how nonsurgical colic or ileus responds to acupuncture along the back. Points on the pelvic limb are important to regulate intestinal motility also, as explored next.
How Camelid Acupuncture Differs from That in Other Species
The route to reproducible and effective neuromodulation (or acupuncture treatment) is selection and stimulation of the appropriate nerves (or acupuncture points) that produce the intended healing effect.13,29–33 Thus, the variability in veterinary acupuncture point locations throughout recorded history leads to confusion and uneven treatment outcomes. Much more information has become available for equine acupuncture as opposed to that for camelids, which raises even more questions about their truly transpositional locations. As Ramey wrote, “Animal acupuncture points have been derived from Chinese point drawings as well as from transposing one or more systems of human acupuncture points onto animal anatomy. Published charts of supposed traditional and transpositional points in horses have failed to agree on a single point of association.”34
Little has been written about camelid acupuncture, in particular, and as a result, veterinary acupuncturists extrapolate needling techniques from other more commonly treated species such as the horse. Diagrams illustrating acupuncture points and channels on camelids are difficult to find and often out of date, originating long before the veterinary profession took to transposing the elaborate point system from humans to nonhuman anatomy.35 Performing acupuncture on camelids differs from treating other species not only because of the unique behaviors of camelids but also because of the thickness of their skin, which means that clinicians need to make modifications in their needling technique.
Camelid Acupuncture: A Practical Approach
Acupuncture in the Camelid
Since the mechanisms of acupuncture have been discussed previously, this portion of the text will deal with specific situations in which acupuncture, aided by manual therapy and other conventional therapies, may be beneficial. Camelids, in general, are excellent acupuncture patients, as they are “good responders.” They tolerate needling well, except in the legs, usually below the carpus and tarsus. They seem to be very sensitive to needling, so I prefer the silicone coated smaller needles (0.3 millimeters [mm] ×30 mm and smaller). Longer needles are often used only to aid in locating them in the fiber. When needling camelids, it is best to use moderate restraint, only controlling their movement but not forcefully holding them. Electroacupuncture and aquapuncture have not shown consistently to be of any further benefit than dry needling in the camelid. (Electroacupuncture is most beneficial in dealing with neurologic disorders such as facial paralysis or spinal cord injury). Length of time of each needling session is, as in any other species, dependent on the animal’s tolerance and the objective of the therapy. Stimulation of the needles may be done throughout the session by gently spinning them periodically, wrapping the underlying tissue around the needle shaft, stimulating the myofascial planes. The needles should be spun in both directions to prevent the tissue from being wrapped tightly around the needle, resulting in a stuck needle. All this depends on the animal’s tolerance of the needles and needle stimulation. The acupuncture session should be a relaxed and quiet period, not a battle. Frequency of needling is not unlike other species and will vary from once or twice a week to three times the first 2 weeks then monthly as needed to maintain the effect.
Anatomic Considerations in Camelid Acupuncture
As this anatomic review stresses, transposition of acupuncture points in the camelid is difficult. The use of command points, the points below the carpus and the tarsus, is very difficult for not only this reason but also explains the difficulty in needling the points in the legs of the camelid. The camelid’s legs are very sensitive, so the camelid is protective of this area, making needling them in the nonsedated or neurologically sound camelid difficult at best. Often lower limb points are best used in those paralyzed or paretic animals. Ting points have not truly been identified as yet, and points used around P3 and the nail can best be explained as local points stimulating the distal nerves of the limb.
As in all veterinary patients, acupuncture and manual therapy techniques are best utilized as complementary care modalities used in conjunction with conventional therapies. Their popularity and use are increasing as a secondary, adjunctive therapy, especially in complicated medical or surgical cases, in economically challenging situations, or in chronic nonresponsive conventional patients as in those with chronic arthritic pain. The most common tranpositional points in the camelid similar to those of other species are listed in Box 54-2.
Diagnostic Acupuncture (Myofascial or Manual Therapy) Examination in the Camelid
DAPE is being utilized in camelid practice to aid in the diagnosis of disease or is used to identify regions of pain. These painful regions identified may be secondary to pain elsewhere in the body, that is, it may be referred pain. As an example, if BL-13, is a painful or sensitive (Ah Shi) point, which is located between the longissimus and iliocostalis muscles bilaterally at the third intercostal space in the camelid, it may be painful for numerous reasons. These reasons include local trauma to the area, pain associated with wither issues (T-1-T6), ipsilateral hock issues, lung disease, rib bruising, and local trigger points. Another example is the identification of a trigger point that is in or near the deltoid region. This point is between the long and lateral head of the triceps at or near an acupuncture point SI-9. This may indicate local shoulder pain or pathology associated with lumbosacral pain, sacroiliac pain, coxofemoral dysfunction or pain, or pelvic or sacral pain. This point is very commonly reactive and pathologic in camelids with osteoarthritis in the coxofemoral, sacroiliac, or lumbosacral joint. Without treatment of this trigger point, the camelid may never respond to conventional medical approaches as expected. These are classically the patients that continue to be in pain or are nonresponders to nonsteroidal medications. By putting together a puzzle of painful regions, with DAPE, often it is possible to focus on more subtle issues of pain or loss of motion and correct these issues via conventional therapies or acupuncture and manual therapy. This chapter includes examples of DAPE points and examination protocols. Much investigative work still needs to be done in the camelid to further evaluate the neurology involved in many of these points. The points listed in this chapter are those extrapolated from other species and are derived from the work of many other veterinarians. The success of DAPE in the camelid is based on a good conventional workup and serves as a guideline for pinpointing other or related pathologies.
Manual therapy is a term that is used to include chiropractic, osteopathy, massage, and physical therapy. It is a means of manipulating and stimulating receptors in the body and a means of identifying areas or sites of pain or body dysfunction. Most joint injuries are secondary to a failure of the soft tissue of the supporting structures. These supporting structures are most commonly the muscles surrounding a joint. For optimal muscle health, the muscle must have motion through active neurostimulation, glucose, and oxygen. Manual therapy is a means of maintaining good joint and muscle health through stimulation of the mechanoreceptors as well as muscle spindle cells. Efficiency of a joint is dependent on the efficiency of the muscles that support it. The health or efficiency of the muscle is dependent on the frequency of firing of the motor neuron supply to that muscle. The frequency of firing of the motor neurons is dependent on the summation of neural influences in a multimodal system. This summation of neural influences is then dependent on the spinal cord reflexes, brain, and integration of sensory input from the environment. Receptors that both acupuncture and manual therapy target are nociceptors (A-δ, C-fibers). A-delta fibers are very small, slow, slightly myelinated nerves that carry sharp pain. A-δ fibers are responsible for the “De Qi,” a term used in Chinese medicine, which means muscle myofascial contraction or fasciculation upon stimulation via a needle or manipulation. Mechanoreceptors are those receptors that transduce the somatic sensation regarding touch, joint position, and vibratory sensation to the CNS. These sensations are carried to the dorsal horn of the spinal column through large-diameter myelinated fibers 1A and 1B, which are very fast fibers, which is the basis for the gate control theory of pain control. The gate control theory states that by eliciting stimulation of the very fast myelinated 1A and 1B neurons as well as the α-motor neuron, their arrival at the spinal segment, before the slower, harder-to-stimulate nociceptors A-δ and C-fibers do, may dampen the perception of pain. In summary, it is the summation of all excitatory and inhibitory influences on the motor neuron that will determine its frequency of firing and thus its strength.
Box 54-3 lists a few of the diagnostic acupuncture points being utilized in the camelid. Those in bold print type are those points that have good repeatability and tend to be more reliable.