Exercise-Induced Pulmonary Hemorrhage


Chapter 58

Exercise-Induced Pulmonary Hemorrhage



Alice Stack



Prevalence


Exercise-induced pulmonary hemorrhage (EIPH) is a common condition of intensely exercising horses and occurs in up to 75% of horses that race. However, studies have indicated that when horses are evaluated by means of tracheobronchoscopy after each of three races, blood is observed in the large airways of all horses (100%) on at least one of these evaluations. Although the condition is most commonly identified in racing Thoroughbreds, and to a similar extent in Standardbreds, EIPH has also been described in other breeds, such as racing Quarter Horses and polo ponies.



Effect on Performance


Exercise-induced pulmonary hemorrhage has a negative effect on racehorse performance. In a study performed in Australia in which 744 Thoroughbred racehorses were evaluated by endoscopy after racing, it was determined that horses with either mild EIPH or no evidence of blood in the large airways were four times as likely to win and almost twice as likely to place in the top three as horses with moderate or severe EIPH.



Risk Factors


Exercise-induced pulmonary hemorrhage affects most, if not all, intensely exercising horses to some degree. Besides exercise, other risk factors for EIPH have not been consistently identified. In the largest study evaluating risk factors for EIPH, horses with more than 50 lifetime starts are 1.8 times as likely to have any evidence of EIPH as those with 40 starts or less. Age and sex are not associated with EIPH risk, whereas ambient temperatures less than 68° F (20° C) and a longer time between race finish and examination (up to 60 minutes) are associated with an increased risk for EIPH being diagnosed with endoscopy.


Risk factors for postrace epistaxis, which is probably a manifestation of severe EIPH, and EIPH that is diagnosed only endoscopically are not identical. Rather, epistaxis is observed more commonly in older racing animals than in 2-year-olds, in mares more than in stallions, and after shorter, faster races (<1 mile or 1600 meters) than after longer ones.



Pathophysiology


Pathogenesis of EIPH


To discuss therapeutic approaches to this condition, both the pathology and how it relates to the proposed theories of pathogenesis must first be described in some detail. Although extensive descriptions of the clinical and pathologic features of EIPH exist in the literature, critical information detailing exact mechanisms of the condition is still lacking.


The first, and until recently the most comprehensive, review of EIPH pathology was performed more than 20 years ago. Specifically, grossly evident pleural discoloration (blue-black) of the caudodorsal lung regions was seen, and on histologic evaluation, extensive hemosiderosis, angiogenesis, pleural and septal fibrosis, and bronchiolitis (small airway inflammatory disease) were consistent findings. Authors of that study proposed that bronchiolitis played a causative role in EIPH. However, several lines of evidence exist that do not support this relationship.


First, in more recent studies, bronchiolitis was not found in association with the other histopathologic features of EIPH. Second, in an epidemiologic study performed in the United Kingdom, some association between inflammatory airway disease and EIPH was detected in Thoroughbreds in training. However, this association cannot be interpreted as a cause-and-effect relationship because both conditions have a high prevalence in that study population. Finally, if airway inflammation was a significant contributing factor, routine treatments for inflammatory airway disease, such as systemic or nebulized corticosteroids and nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drugs, with or without antimicrobial therapy, would be expected to control EIPH. Although the latter treatments have never been formally investigated, in a clinical setting at least, such therapeutic regimens are not perceived to affect EIPH incidence or severity.


A breakthrough study in 1993 demonstrated that pulmonary capillary rupture or disruption was commonly detected in lung tissue that had evidence of extravasation of red blood cells. These extravascular red cells were found both in the pulmonary interstitium and in surrounding alveolar airspaces. This work strongly implicated the pulmonary circulation as the source of hemorrhage in EIPH, and on the basis of these data, it was proposed that so-called stress failure of pulmonary capillaries secondary to transient but significant pulmonary circulation hypertension during exercise resulted in capillary disruption. This concept was strongly corroborated by studies that evaluated the magnitude of blood pressures in the horse’s pulmonary circulation during exercise. Pulmonary arterial pressures of approximately 100 mm Hg are reported, and from these measurements, pulmonary capillary pressures from 72.5 to 83.3 mm Hg can be calculated. Pressures of these magnitudes are unparalleled in any other mammalian species that has been investigated. This information, when considered in the context of a study that described the breaking strength of the horse’s pulmonary capillaries (75 mm Hg), makes pulmonary capillary stress failure a plausible theory of pathogenesis for EIPH. However, this theory does not account for the pathology seen in the lungs of horses with EIPH.



Pathology


More recent descriptions of the pathologic features of EIPH have identified a novel lesion in the lungs of horses affected by EIPH—that of venous remodeling. This lesion affects small pulmonary veins (a caliber range of 100 to 200 µm outer diameter) and is characterized mainly by accumulation of adventitial collagen and, in some vessels, smooth muscle hyperplasia. In the most severely affected vessels, the lumen is significantly obstructed. Increases in pressure and shearing stresses, such as would be associated with high-flow states, are known stimuli of vascular remodeling in other species. Because, during exercise, pulmonary blood flow and vascular pressures increase dramatically, these stimuli are likely causes of pulmonary vein remodeling. Venous remodeling and resultant luminal occlusion, loss of vessel compliance, or both will have a profound effect on pressures in upstream vessels, in this instance the pulmonary capillaries. Indeed, in cases of complete occlusion of pulmonary veins, pulmonary capillary pressures during exercise would equal pulmonary arterial pressures (96.5 mm Hg) and result in a greater likelihood of capillary wall rupture. Interstitial hemorrhage and hemosiderosis contribute to the fibrotic processes that constitute a significant lesion in affected tissues. This relationship between venous remodeling and EIPH is supported by the observation that venous remodeling, hemosiderosis, and fibrosis are co-localized in affected lung regions.


During training and racing, each exercise bout raises pulmonary vascular pressure, and these repeated high-pressure events likely result in venous remodeling, bleeding, and fibrosis. It is not surprising therefore that higher numbers of lifetime race starts are associated with increased risk for EIPH.


Lesions of EIPH are found predominantly in the caudodorsal region of the lungs. Interestingly, blood flow is also preferentially distributed to the caudodorsal areas at rest and during exercise. It is likely that increased pressures and flow in this region account for the characteristic distribution of EIPH pathology.


A competing theory of pathogenesis to explain this unique distribution of EIPH lesions in the caudodorsal lung emerged in the 1990s and will be mentioned here for the sake of completeness. This theory attributes the caudodorsal lesions to the transmission of concussive forces from the thoracic limb to the lung tissue through the thoracic wall, or locomotory impact-induced trauma, which in turn results in shearing injury of the caudodorsal lung regions. This is similar to the contrecoup explanation of the distribution of intracranial hemorrhage after impact on the front of the cranium. At present, this theory is a modeling concept, does not account for the specific pathologic features of the disease such as venous remodeling, and lacks supporting data.



Clinical Signs


Horses with EIPH do not typically manifest signs of systemic disease, and on physical examination, the only detectable abnormality may be epistaxis. Because epistaxis is observed in about 0.15% of horses that race, and it is known through use of other diagnostic techniques that most horses experience some degree of EIPH, absence of epistaxis does not rule out EIPH.



Diagnosis


The clinical evaluation of any horse with suspected EIPH, regardless of the breed, should involve careful cardiac auscultation. The rationale for this is that horses with atrial fibrillation have higher-than-normal pulmonary artery pressures during exercise and, with the reduced passive ventricular filling phase seen at high heart rates, pulmonary venous congestion and capillary rupture are likely to result. Epistaxis has been reported in association with atrial fibrillation in light-horse breeds. In draft horses with atrial fibrillation, severe EIPH is a common observation, in the author’s clinical experience.


Diagnosis of EIPH in the horse is performed relative easily with one or a combination of the following techniques: observation, tracheobronchoscopy, and bronchoalveolar lavage.




Tracheobronchoscopy


This simple diagnostic technique should be performed within 60 to 90 minutes of finishing exercise because earlier or later evaluations may result in false-negative diagnoses. Endoscopy readily confirms the lungs as the source of the bleeding (versus pharyngeal or nasal structures). A five-point grading system, which has an established repeatability, is commonly used to describe tracheobronchoscopic findings (Table 58-1). It is not known how much bleeding has to occur before blood becomes visible in the large airways, and on the basis of bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL) data (see below), it is considered highly likely that horses bleed to some degree even when the trachea and large airways are free of blood on endoscopic examination.


< div class='tao-gold-member'>

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Jul 8, 2016 | Posted by in EQUINE MEDICINE | Comments Off on Exercise-Induced Pulmonary Hemorrhage

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access