Judith Parry Bottle Green Training Ltd, Derby, United Kingdom Before looking at the laws relevant to veterinary nursing, it is important to understand where laws come from and the types of laws that exist. Have you ever considered why laws are made and why we need them? Hopefully, after a moment of reflection, you have considered that laws are required to enable society to run in some form of orderly manner and to provide protection. They provide rules and structure for dealing with situations and also provide a system of redress and punishment for any wrongdoing. Laws originate from legislation and can relate to a precedent system, that is, earlier laws or decisions that provide some examples or rules to guide decisions about a case. This guidance can be formalised through the legal system and from Acts of Parliament. An individual law or statute originates from a Bill. This Bill is passed through both the Houses of Parliament (the House of Lords and the House of Commons). Once the Bill has passed through both houses and been debated and voted upon, it ultimately passes to the Crown for Royal Assent. This is a very long and complicated process but ultimately if accepted by both houses, the Bill becomes a law [1]. Any criminal offence is concerned with punishment by the state and is designed to protect society and individuals. There are three types of criminal offence: Civil law is more concerned with harm or loss suffered by an individual as the result of another person. In civil cases, an individual will take action against the person who has caused harm rather than the state. ‘Tort’, this is defined as a wrong against someone’s personal safety, possessions or reputation. The most common civil actions seen within veterinary practice are as follows: The outcome of most civil cases results in financial compensation for damages or may lead to prohibitive measures such as an injunction (an official order given by a law court). The main differences between civil law and criminal law are displayed in Table 3.1. Table 3.1 The main differences between civil law and criminal law. Source: Judith Parry. In the United Kingdom legal system, statutes are laws enacted by Parliament. They are also known as primary legislation or acts of Parliament. Statutes are considered the highest form of law and take precedence over other sources of law, such as common law and judicial precedent. Veterinary Surgeons Act 1966 Animal Welfare Act 2006 Data Protection Act 2018 Public Interest Disclosure Act 1998 Veterinary Medicines Regulations 2013 Ionising Radiation Regulations 2017 The Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons (RCVS) was established through the issuance of a Royal Charter in 1844. This Charter recognised the ‘veterinary art’ as a profession and gave the RCVS the power to administer examinations to the first recognised veterinary surgeons (vets). From this Charter, the VSA 1881 was developed to recognise qualified and unqualified practitioners. The VSA 1966 consolidated all earlier Charters and Acts into one single Act. This Act defines ‘veterinary surgery’ to mean the art and science of veterinary surgery and medicine. This includes: Within the VSA 1966, there are several Schedules. Schedule 1 is concerned with provisions for the council, Schedule 2 is concerned with investigations and disciplinary committees, and Schedule 3 is concerned with what registered veterinary nurses (RVNs) and student veterinary nurses (SVNs) can and cannot do in practice. Schedule 3 of the VSA allows competent non‐veterinarians to perform certain acts of veterinary surgery in order to maintain and promote animal welfare. These non‐qualified persons may be the owner of the animal, household members or other people employed in the care of animals. It gives provision for the administration of first aid to preserve life or reduce pain and suffering. In 1991, the VSA was first amended to recognise the role of the veterinary nurse in law. The VSA 1966 (Schedule 3 Amendment) Order 2002 made provision for vets to direct RVNs or SVNs who they employ to carry out limited acts of veterinary surgery. The RVN must be on the RCVS register for Veterinary Nurses, and the SVN must be officially enrolled as a Student Veterinary Nurse with the RCVS. When looking at owners and animal caregivers, it allows them to administer medications and treatments in order to improve welfare. For example, it enables owners to give prescribed medications to their horses without the need for the vet to be present on site. Owners can perform first aid procedures whilst waiting for veterinary assistance if required. The Schedule 3 amendment also allows for other equine professionals, such as farriers and physiotherapists, to perform certain procedures on horses in their care. However, if the patient is receiving non‐routine care from these professionals, it is likely that a vet will need to delegate the task. For RVNs and SVNs, Schedule 3 states that vets may direct RVNs or SVNs who they employ, to carry out limited veterinary surgery. Under this Schedule 3 exemption, the privilege of giving any medical treatment or carrying out minor surgery, not involving entry into a body cavity, is given to [2]: The RCVS has interpreted these terms as follows [2]: There is a general consensus that RVNs would like to improve recognition of their role and performing Schedule 3 procedures, which can help clarify the status and role of RVNs to the wider veterinary profession and the public. There is, however, no definitive list to describe what minor surgical and medical treatment is, and it is therefore vital that RVNs must always be aware of their level of competence in a task. The pressures of veterinary practice do mean that when RVNs are allowed to perform Schedule 3 procedures, they can improve the smooth running of the practice. They often have the time to give their patients a more personal approach and perform tasks at a pace that maximises animal welfare. This can improve job satisfaction as RVNs feel more fulfilled within their role. Performing these tasks does not, however, come without potential negative outcomes. RVNs are accountable and liable for their actions both within criminal and civil law. RVNs may not feel comfortable with the weight of responsibility associated with performing some of these tasks. This should be respected by the veterinary team. The safest RVN is one who is fully aware of their limitations, as well as their competencies, and is able to put patient welfare at the fore of their decision‐making. The RCVS has produced a ‘SUPERB’ poster as guidance for vets on delegating Schedule 3 tasks to RVNs (Figure 3.1). Lack of clarity surrounding Schedule 3 can often lead to vets being reluctant to delegate Schedule 3 procedures to RVNs. The British Equine Veterinary Association (BEVA) has produced a set of guidelines to help with the interpretation of Schedule 3, with a view to instilling confidence in vets to delegate more Schedule 3 procedures to RVNs in practice. The BEVA Schedule 3 guidelines can be found here: https://www.beva.org.uk/Career‐Support/Nurses/Schedule‐Three The role of the veterinary nurse has advanced significantly over time and RVNs are now accountable and responsible for their actions. Veterinary nursing is now recognised as a profession in its own right. Therefore, it is assumed that RVNs must be professional and responsible people. Before defining professionalism, it is important to understand what a professional is. The Oxford English Dictionary has multiple definitions of ‘professional’; however, the keywords from these definitions are showing skill and being competent [3]. This therefore infers that all professionals should display particular characteristics and skills. It is often understood that a profession is a deliberate career choice, and this suggests a level of long‐term commitment and training. This is certainly the case within the veterinary profession. vets and RVNs must achieve a licence to practice qualification that involves mastery of many body systems and behaviours. Not all professionals need to achieve qualifications to be a professional. There are many occupations where experience and commitment are enough. A professional is recognised as having specialised knowledge that has been acquired through a commitment to develop and improve their skills. These skills are usually quantified through the achievement of qualifications within their field. This knowledge must be up‐to‐date to enable a professional to work to the best possible standard. A professional must be competent and reliable, and work with honesty and integrity. Figure 3.1 RCVS SUPERB poster (2023). Source: Reproduced with kind permission from the RCVS. As far back as 1947, the role of the veterinary nurse was becoming more recognised and Phyllis Peake (vet and veterinary nurse) wrote that a good animal nurse needed ‘a strong vocational call … for self‐sacrifice, tenderness and the ability to consider the patient as an individual’ [4]. These sentiments still resonate with RVNs today. The recognition of veterinary nursing as a profession started with the first Animal Nursing Auxiliary training scheme being approved by the RCVS in 1961. The term ‘veterinary nurse’ was not used until 1984 as the title ‘nurse’ was protected within human medicine until then. Within 30 years of the first training scheme, the VSA was amended to recognise the role of the veterinary nurse in law. From this point, the profession has evolved very quickly with the introduction of further qualifications, such as the Diploma in Advanced Veterinary Nursing. In the year 2000, the very first equine veterinary nurses qualified, and this became a turning point for all veterinary nurses wanting to specialise in treating equine patients. In 2002, the Veterinary Nurses Council was established, and in 2007, the non‐statutory register was introduced. This was a voluntary register where qualified veterinary nurses could choose to sign up. Once on the register, veterinary nurses were able to perform procedures that fell under the remit of Schedule 3 and were accountable for their actions. Now, all newly qualified nurses apply to the RCVS Register to be able to practice as a veterinary nurse in the United Kingdom and make the following declaration: I PROMISE AND SOLEMNLY DECLARE that I will pursue the work of my profession with integrity and accept my responsibilities to the public, my clients, the profession and the Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons, and that, ABOVE ALL, my constant endeavour will be to ensure the health and welfare of animals committed to my care [5]. The RCVS continues to strive for more recognition of the role of the veterinary nurse and alongside the British Veterinary Nursing Association (BVNA), the Veterinary Nursing (VN) Futures project was launched in 2015. This project aimed to provide a view of the future of veterinary nursing and the progress of the profession. With the recognition of the RVN as a professional, there comes with it the need for regulation. This is to protect the people who use the professional services, to enhance the status of RVNs and to help to develop a sound knowledge base, as this is an integral part of professional status. The regulation of veterinary nursing is statutory – this means it is required by law as set out in the VSA 1966. Voluntary regulation is where a code of practice is chosen but not required by law. The Royal Charter of 2015 confirmed the RCVS as the regulator of veterinary nurses. Because statutory regulation is required by law, the regulator has the force of the law to ensure its requirements are upheld. Non‐statutory regulation does not require any Acts of Parliament/laws to ensure requirements are upheld. The RCVS VN Council replaced the Veterinary Nurses Committee in 2002. It is responsible for: Whilst performing the above, the RCVS VN Council must keep animal welfare and good veterinary practice at the forefront of its values. RCVS VN Council consists of: The RCVS VN Council is classed as self‐regulating as it is run mostly by members of the profession but does endeavour to provide some balance with the appointment of lay members. It has been suggested that ideally, there should be a 50 : 50 split between members of the veterinary profession and lay people. An independently run regulatory body would comprise of members outside of the veterinary profession. This could be a government‐run regulatory body. The structure of VN Council is currently under review. Readers are encouraged to check up to date sources for the most accurate information. The General Dental Council and Nursing and Midwifery Council are independent regulatory bodies which comprise of multiple committees. These committees consist of members from both inside and outside of the profession. They have the same aims as the RCVS and core standards: they maintain the register of practitioners, set the standards for practitioners and education providers and investigate complaints. The advantage of self‐regulation is that the regulators have a full understanding of the profession. Therefore, it is anticipated that decisions made would be in the best interests of the profession and its members. However, it could be said that independent regulation would lead to greater transparency and ensure that members are held fully accountable. RCVS council is responsible for the governance of the RCVS college and its members as defined in Schedules 1 and 2 of the VSA 1966. It comprises of vets from veterinary universities, RVNs, lay members and the chief veterinary officer (CVO). The structure of RCVS Council is currently under review. Readers are encouraged to check up to date sources for the most accurate information. In summary, the RCVS and VN Council are there to maintain the registers of vets and RVNs who are qualified to practice, and to guide and monitor the quality of education within the sector. They aim to ensure good ethical practice is adhered to, ensure continuous improvement in welfare of patients and protection for people who use veterinary services. The introduction of the RCVS practice standards scheme (PSS) aims to raise standards across the profession. The RCVS has produced a Code of Professional Conduct for Veterinary Nurses. Within this code, there are five main principles of practice: These five principles are set to help RVNs protect and promote the health and welfare of patients within their care. This code provides essential professional guidance for practising RVNs over six main themes: There are also many additional supporting documents covering commonly encountered scenarios an RVN may experience and to provide a framework of best practices for an RVN to follow. Areas of practice covered include client confidentiality, referrals and second opinions and clinical governance. The RCVS also has a veterinary nurse disciplinary procedures policy should any concerns be raised about an RVN. This involves a three‐stage process which is comparable to the disciplinary process in place for vets: Potential courses of action: Both stages one and two are confidential; however, stage three is usually public and may be listed on the RCVS website. The RCVS will only deal with serious concerns that affect a person’s ability to practice as an RVN. For example, a serious breach of the code of professional conduct or serious criminal convictions [6]. The RCVS has a set of rules that have been approved by the VN Council and provide guidance for anyone wishing to register. These rules include: What are ethics and where do they come from?
3
Professional Veterinary Nursing Responsibilities
3.1 The Legal Framework for Veterinary Nursing Practice
Why Do We Have Laws?
Where Do These Laws Come From?
Criminal Law
Civil Law
Factors
Civil law
Criminal law
Redress (remedy or compensation for wrong doing or a grievance)
May be fines/damages or injunctions
Maybe a custodial sentence, fine or probation
Who is involved?
Person versus Person
Crown versus Accused
Laws which may be affected within the Veterinary field
Criminal Damages Act 1971Contract Law
Animal Welfare Act 2006Veterinary Surgeons Act 1966Veterinary Medicines Regulations 2013
Decision
On the balance of probabilities
Beyond reasonable doubt
Statutes
Which Statutes are Most Relevant to Me as a Veterinary Nurse?
The Veterinary Surgeons Act (VSA) 1966
The VSA 1966 (Schedule 3 Amendment) Order 2002
What Does This All Really Mean?
What RVNs and SVNs Cannot Do
Should RVNs and SVNs Perform Procedures that Fall Under the Remit of Schedule 3?
3.2 Professional Status and Accountability
Professionalism
What Makes a Professional RVN?
Purpose and Principles of Professional Regulation
What Does Statutory Regulation Mean?
RCVS VN Registration Rules 2017
3.3 Ethical Principles
The Difference Between Ethics and Morals
Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel
Full access? Get Clinical Tree