Curriculum Mapping

Chapter 3
Curriculum Mapping


Karen Dyer Inzana


Virginia-Maryland College of Veterinary Medicine, Virginia Tech, USA


Introduction


Pressure from accrediting agents for curricula to focus on student achievement rather than the educational process has driven curricular reform in all health professions, including veterinary medicine. Veterinary educators are currently striving for better, more effective means of developing professionals who are competent to take on the many challenges of modern veterinary practice on graduation. Curriculum mapping is a critical tool to facilitate educational reform. When used to its fullest potential, a well-designed curriculum map should ensure appropriate coverage of content, align teaching and learning with curriculum goals, improve integration across the curriculum, and facilitate demonstration of outcomes to external stakeholders and accrediting agencies (Harden, 2001; Bell, Ellaway, and Rhind, 2009). However, there are additional benefits since the process itself creates an environment for collaboration, reflection on practice, and discussion of individual and collective beliefs about not only what is being taught, but how and why it is being taught (Bester and Scholtz, 2012; Jacobs, 1997; Udelhofen, 2005; Uchiyama and Radin, 2009).


The concept of curriculum mapping was originated in the 1980s by Fenwick English as a means of documenting the learning activities occurring in elementary and high schools (English, 1980). Heidi Hayes Jacobs expanded this concept to an electronic format and has, alongside Susan Udelhofen, become a leading figure in advancing curriculum mapping in K-12 education (Jacobs, 1997; Udelhofen, 2005). While its roots are in elementary education, curriculum mapping has become commonplace in medical education (Willett, 2008; Ellaway et al., 2014). In fact, the Data Collection Instrument required by the Liaison Committee on Medical Education (LCME) has become so lengthy and detailed, it is almost impossible to address all the information required for medical school accreditation without an electronic curriculum map (LCME, 2015). In 1999, the American Association of Medical Colleges (AAMC) released an online curriculum management and information tool (CurrMIT) designed to facilitate curriculum data collection and reporting (Cohen, 2000; Salas et al., 2003; Cottrell, Linger, and Shumway, 2004). Unfortunately, the format of CurrMIT proved too rigid to accommodate the wide variety of medical school structures so, with the help of MedBiquitous, AAMC created a newer data based called Curriculum Inventory and Reports (CIR; AAMC, 2016). Rather than being a tool to enter curricular data directly, CIR became a tool to house and compare data from different medical education programs (Ellaway et al., 2014). It was designed to receive data from a variety of management systems and link individual school learning outcomes with an overarching competency framework (Englander et al., 2013). CIR is able to generate a variety of reports for the LCME from the data entered, but also can compare one school’s data with dozens of other programs. In the 2015 reporting year, 135 medical colleges in the United States and Canada used CIR to catalog their curriculum structure, content, and delivery methods as well as their different assessment methods, providing an unprecedented opportunity to compare approaches and benchmark best practices in medical education.


Getting Started


Step 1: Deciding on Content


The most common content elements in a curriculum map include the sequencing of courses, the course goals or objectives, the learning activities that comprise a course with the intended learning objectives attached to each of these activities, and the assessment tools used to measure these objectives. While the aim of true competency-based educational curricula is to de-emphasize time-based training (Frank et al., 2010), the American Veterinary Medical Association’s (AVMA) Council on Education (COE) accreditation policies and procedures require that all accredited veterinary colleges contain a minimum of four academic years of education, at least one year of which consists of hands-on clinical education. Therefore, most veterinary schools have a relatively rigid sequence of preclinical and clinical instruction. Mapping in a veterinary context typically is based on the sequence in which courses are delivered during Year 1, Year 2, and so on. Using the curriculum calendar as a starting point not only provides some organization for the map, but constitutes a critical element of how a given course content relates to both previous and future content.


Step 2: Selecting the Database


There are a number of web-based databases that have been developed for the purpose of curriculum mapping. A list of those programs that were developed primarily for medical education and integrate with the CIR is provided in Table 3.1.


Table 3.1 Software utilized for curriculum mapping in medical education













































Only gold members can continue reading. Log In or Register to continue

Stay updated, free articles. Join our Telegram channel

Oct 15, 2017 | Posted by in GENERAL | Comments Off on Curriculum Mapping

Full access? Get Clinical Tree

Get Clinical Tree app for offline access
Name Web site Notes
Illios http://meded.ucsf.edu/tee/ilios-curriculum-management

  • Non-profit, open-source MIT (management and information tool)
  • Integrates with online course learning management systems, include Moodle, Blackboard, and Canvas
TUSK http://tusk.tufts.edu/about/overview

  • Non-profit
  • Online course learning management system integrated with curriculum management
4iQ www.4iqsolutions.com

  • Commercial
  • Online course learning management system integrated with curriculum management
ALLOFE www.allofe.com

  • Commercial suite of programs with secure testing features, scheduling, and student data management
E*Value www.medhub.com

  • Commercial
  • Scheduling
  • Student data management
Entrada www.entrada-project.org

  • Open source or commercial
  • Scheduling
  • Student data management
  • Integrates with learning management systems
Knowledge 4 You knowledge4you.com

  • Commercial
  • Scheduling
  • Student data management
LCMS+ lcmsplus.com

  • Commercial
  • Scheduling
  • Student data management
Medhub www.medhub.com

  • Commercial
  • Scheduling
  • Student data management
New Innovations